Kiehl’s Solutions for Flaky/Itchy Scalp & Dandruff

Thursday February 7, 2013 | Hair Care

Let’s get something straight.

Flaky/itchy scalp should not be confused with dandruff. They are two different problems having to do with the scalp. And both are equally as annoying.

I’ve recently been using two different scalp treatments by Kiehl’s.

Both essentially help to clean the scalp. But one is designed for loosening flaky buildup. While the other is used specifically to help treat dandruff.

Kiehl's Micro-Exfoliating Scalp Treatment & Scalp Purifying Dandruff Shampoo

Kiehl’s is an American cosmetics brand that was founded in 1851. That’s really old for a cosmetics brand.

The first thing you will notice about their products is their packaging. It’s Minimalist. Understated. And utterly Brilliant.

There is nothing on the product itself except text about the product itself. What is so darn clever about this way of presenting products is the absence of any marketing gimmick. They want you to focus only on two things. The product. And what it can do for you.

So the two products we’ll look at today are:

1) Kiehl’s Deep Micro-Exfoliating Scalp Treatment

Kiehl's Micro-Exfoliating Scalp Treatment

Micronized Apricot Seed Kiehl's

This is a scalp treatment that is formulated with Vitreoscilla Ferment to help restore a healthy balance to the scalp. The exfoliation feature comes from the micronized Apricot Seed and Argan Shells which you can see in the photo above. These exfoliating beads help to gently and effectively exfoliate and loosen flaky buildup. The treatment purifies and prepares the scalp for shampooing.

Ingredients

Aqua, Phenoxyethanol, Carbomer, Argania Spinosa Shell Powder, Prunus Armeniaca Seed Powder (Apricot Seed Powder), Menthol, Vitreoscilla Ferment, Sodium Hydroxide, Rosmarinus Officinalis (Rosemary Leaf Oil), Thymus Mastichina Flower Oil, Linalool

FYI: The active ingredient, Vitreoscilla Ferment, is an extract of bacterial culture used to help cells utilize oxygen better. Though I’m not really sure what that has to do with the scalp.

How To Use

Apply to dry or moist scalp before shampooing. Gently massage. Leave on for up to five minutes before rinsing thoroughly. Follow with Kiehl’s Shampoo. Use 1-2 times a week as needed.

My Experience

This product looks like one of my old facial exfoliating creams that had apricot seed powder in it. The texture of this is gel-like, and the smell is minty and herbal.

When you apply this to your scalp, the smell gets stronger and reminds me of Vick’s vapor rub.

Applying this to my scalp was tricky at first because I have A LOT of hair. And to use this effecitvely, you have to get it directly on your scalp. So when I first used it, I ended up wasting a lot of it just trying to get past my hair and onto my scalp.

Once the product is applied, I get a very cooling/refreshing sensation. While gently massaging the exfoliating beads in circular motions throughout my head, I feel incredibly relaxed.

Obviously, I would be that much more relaxed if I had someone else to do the massaging for me.

Results

After using this Kiehl’s micro-exfoliating scalp treatment (in conjunction with the Kiehl’s dandruff shampoo), I can go TWO WEEKS before my scalp even begins to hint at being aggravating. Two weeks, people! That’s a looong period of itchy-free relief for me. I used to be able to go three days tops before my scalp got too itchy and I had to do something about it. So this Kiehl’s scalp treatment combo has worked quite well for me.

Also, one of the main reasons I went for this product is because it does not excessively strip my hair of its natural oils. My hair still looks a bit dry after using this product, but not as dry as it did with other products (mainly the René Furterer Lightness Regulating Shampoo that I’d been using. You can read my review of it here).

I’d never before encountered or used an exfoliating scrub for my scalp. So I think this concept is quite fresh and brilliant.

What I like about it

– Feels really cooling on the scalp
– Doesn’t dry my hair (at least not too much)
– Helps remove excess buildup on the scalp

What I didn’t like about it

– Smells a bit like Vick’s vapor rub
– Difficult to get on your scalp

My Tips on using this product

The point of this product is to get it directly on your scalp. If you’re like me and you’ve got long hair and lots of it, then this is a tip on how to apply this product. It might seem silly, but trust me, if you do this you will end up wasting very little of this (rather pricey) product.

So what I’ve been doing is this. I squeeze out the amount that I want onto a non-stick surface, like a glass plate or bowl. Then with one hand, I separate a long section of my hair along my scalp. Then with the other hand, I rub the pads of my fingers with the exfoliating gel. I then glide them over the exposed section of my scalp. Repeat. I move to the next section of my scalp and with my dry hand, I separate another long section of my hair and apply the product with the other hand until I get every inch of my scalp the best that I can.

If you do this, you should need no more than a tablespoon’s worth of this stuff.

How Much

€21.50 for 100 ml bottle / $20.00 for 3.4 fl oz bottle

2) Kiehl’s Scalp Purifying Pyrithione Zinc Dandruff Shampoo

Kiehl's Scalp Purifying Pyrithione Zinc Dandruff Shampoo

Pyrithione Zinc is an active anti-dandruff ingredient. This shampoo helps to deeply cleanse the hair and scalp. But specifically, it’s designed to help prevent the recurrence of symptoms associated with dandruff. It contains a blend of Rosemary Leaf and Marjoram Oil essential oils.

Ingredients

Aqua (Water), Sodium Laureth Sulfate, Disodium Cocoamphodiacetate, Sodium Chloride, Glycol Distearate, Zinc Pyrithione, PPG-5-Ceteth-20, Sodium Benzoate, Carbomer, Polyquaternium-10, Salicylic Acid, Menthol, Citric Acid, Rosmarinus Officinalis Leaf Oil (Rosemary Leaf Oil), Thymus Mastichina Flower Oil, Linalool, Aloe Barbadensis/Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Juice, Sodium Hydroxide

How To Use

Shake well. Lather. Rinse. In case of contact with eyes, rinse them immediately. For best results, use at least twice a week or as directed by a doctor.

My Experience

The shampoo is white with a creamy, sticky texture and a minty smell.

When I first applied this shampoo, I noticed that my eyes stung a bit though I’m pretty sure I hadn’t gotten any of it in my eyes. I think my eyes were affected by the smell. Which is odd, because the scent is not as strong or Vick’s vapor rub-y as the exfoliating scrub.

The second time I used this however, I didn’t have this same experience.

Once applied, this shampoo gives me the same cooling/refreshing sensation as I do from the exfoliating scrub. While massaging this onto my scalp, the shampoo gets sudsy at first. But that quickly goes away.

Then when I rinse it off, I notice that the water running down the drain has a brownish gray tinge to it. I wonder where that color is coming from, since the shampoo is milky white when it comes out of the bottle. I don’t think it’s because I have terribly dirty hair. I noticed the same things happens whenever I use René Furterer’s Lightness Regulating Shampoo.

Results

Using Kiehl’s Dandruff Shampoo in conjuction with the micro-exfoliating scalp treatment relieves me of itchy, flaky scalp for about two weeks. And it doesn’t excessively strip my hair of its natural oils. So this Kiehl’s scalp treatment combo has worked quite well for me.

What I like about it

– Feels really cooling and soothing for my scalp
– Doesn’t dry my hair
– It doesn’t smell like Vick’s vapor rub
– I can go two weeks without suffering from my usual scalp problems

What I didn’t like about it

– At first, it kind of stung my eyes a little

My tips on using this product

Before buying this product, you should probably figure out first if you actually suffer from dandruff or from flaky/itchy scalp. As I first mentioned above, the two shouldn’t be confused for one another.

If you do have dandruff, then this is a real deal treatment shampoo and you should follow its recommendation of using this at least twice a week.

How Much

€17.00 for 250 ml bottle / $18 for 8.4 fl oz bottle

CONCLUDING THOUGHTS 

This Kiehl’s scalp treatment duo has given me longer lasting relief than other treatments that I’ve tried before. But I wonder if all I really need is just the micro-exfoliating scalp treatment. And whether I could have gotten the same relief even without the dandruff shampoo.

I’ve only used them together, so I haven’t been able to see whether one will work just as well without the other. This is something that I will have to test out and see in the coming weeks.

I’m not as crazy about the dandruff shampoo as I am about the scalp exfoliating scrub.  But as much as I like these products and despite how well they’ve worked for me, the fact of the matter is, they provide me with only temporary relief.

I want to be rid of my scalp problems for good. And I don’t think these products are gonna do it.

So that’s why, in the next post, we are going to be talking about the difference between flaky/itchy scalp and dandruff.

Because what I want to know are possible solutions that will get rid of them FOREVER.

Who’s with me?

9 Responses to “Kiehl’s Solutions for Flaky/Itchy Scalp & Dandruff”

  1. Another great post. I find that natural and organic hair treatments don’t irritate my scalp. The flaking can be so embarrassing and annoying.

    I’m going to check out my kiehl’s counter to see if they have a trial size of these shampoo’s and scalp scrub :)

    • Kareen says:

      Hey Sun, thanks! What natural and organic hair treatments do use? For me, what I really like about the exfoliating scrub is that it removes product buildup, which can come about from use of too many hair products.

  2. Sunny says:

    Thanks for such a detailed review, Kareen! I sometimes have itchy scalp too. Recently I bought this scalp treatment oil from Aesop that has been working wonders! I normally put oil in my hair the night before I shampoo it, so I’m really used to it. It definitely helps too! Now I want to check out this scalp scrub!

  3. Philippe says:

    Glad you liked it, the scent is very powerful but the results are good enough to keep using for me :)

  4. youngforgood says:

    Have you tried or heard about this one: http://www.philipkingsley.co.uk/shampoo/philip-kingsley-flaky-itchy-scalp-shampoo.html ?
    I haven’t tried it yet but I hear it’s amazing. Especially for itchy scalp, not sure about dandruff.

  5. Mike says:

    I used to use Head and Shoulders until I found chemical free products by Amyke Design. Hands down they are fantastic! I use the Pure Essential 2 in 1 ( anti- dandruff ) and the scalp treatment which is once a week. My whole family now uses and adores an array of her stuff. She also has super customer service and a lot of positive reviews. You should check her site out. All of her shampoos and conditioners are very healing and everyone’s hair seems to be getting hethier and healthier as time goes by!
    http://www.etsy.com/shop/amykedesign

Leave a Reply